	Pros	Cons
14K Gold	More affordable, durable	Nickel content may cause allergic reaction.
18K Gold	Contains more gold, higher investment value	Less durable due to higher gold content. Nickel content may cause allergic reaction.
Platinum	Excellent investment value, very durable	Can be expensive

	Pros	Cons
White Gold	More durable than yellow gold, can replicate look of platinum at a lower price	Will tarnish over time requiring maintenance (need to re-rhodium plate)
Yellow Gold	Does not tarnish - will always retain yellow color, traditionally most popular metal for rings	More easily scratched than white gold due to no rhodium plating
Rose Gold	Will not tarnish, extremely durable due to presence of copper	Copper will naturally darken over time - can be good or bad depending on preference
Platinum	Very durable material, best for gem security (prongs do not bend or break easily)	Can be expensive

Gemstone Engagement Rings

Gemstones made by nature, settings carefully handcrafted in NYC for you.

Flexible Financing
* Up to 24 month term
* No Credit Check Available
* 0% APR Available

Shop by Gemstone

By Direct - We own our entire inventory - offering you unmatched selection, pricing and details about each item. Contact our gemologists on staff to discuss specific gemstones in real time

Shop By Style

Our gemstone engagement ring collection
offers hand-crafted pieces of unforgettable luxury that are perfect for any occasion.

Shop All

Solitaire

Petite and delicate, a solitaire setting is the epitome of timeless elegance

Three Stone

Browse our distinctive and symbolic three stone designs

Halo

Add emphasis and sparkle to your main attraction with our halo collection

Side Stones

Combining classic with contemporary, browse our side stone collections

Antique

Explore the mesmerizing uniqueness of our antique collection

Celtic

For a symbol of eternal love and protection, browse our celtic collection

Wedding Sets

From antique- inspired to modern love story - view our unique wedding collection

Astrological

Designed to touch the skin, each piece is meticulously crafted

Engagement

Find the perfect ring for your momentous occasion in our engagement collection

Men's Ring

Shop our wide range of men's ring from classic to accented designs

Two Stone

Stack on the sparkle. Browse our collection of classic and unique styles

Buy direct. No middleman. Mines to your doorstep.

Our mission is to educate customers with full transparency. All jewelry handcrafted in NYC. Luxury and Quality doesn’t have to come at a cost – its standard at GemsNY!

View Gems in 360
All Gems Certified
100% Conflict Free
Best Price Guarantee
Lifetime Warranty

Shop Popular Gemstone Engagement Rings

See our favorites to get inspired

R10211DM

Traditional Solitaire

R11835DM

Princess Diana Replica

R10694DM

Round & Marquise Diamond Engagement Ring

R11779DM

Halo

R10264DM

Classic Pave

R11659DM

Celtic

R11357DM

Split Shank

R11329DM

Bypass

RB11356DM

Wedding Set

R11744DM

Antique

Easy Financing

We make it easy to buy now and pay later so you don't need to wait to get your dream gemstones and jewelry

Up to 24 months financing available. Prequalify now
Choose from 3, 6, 9 or 12 months interest free payments with no credit check. Learn More
With Paypal Credit, no interest if paid in full in 6 months or pay in 4 payments. Learn more
Layaway options are available. Contact us at info@gemsny.com

Shop by Metal

Our diamond and gemstone fine jewelry collection
offers hand-crafted pieces of unforgettable luxury that are perfect for any occasion.

Shop All

Consult with a Jewelry Specialist

A more thoughtful way to experience fine jewelry, built around you.

Visit Showroom

December 24th	Closed
December 25th	Closed
December 26th	10am to 5pm
December 27th	10am to 5pm
December 28th	Closed
December 29th	Closed
December 30th	10am to 5pm
December 31st	Closed
January 1st	Closed
January 2nd	Resume regular business hours