Gemstone Engagement Ring Gemstone Engagement Ring

Gemstone Engagement Rings

Gemstones made by nature, settings carefully handcrafted in NYC for you and for your precious moment. Find the perfect ring from our precious and semiprecious gemstone rings collection.

  • Split your payment Flexible Financing

  • customer can pay in up to 2 years * Up to 36 months term

  • Credit history icon* No Credit Check Available

  • Interest Free Icon * 0% APR Available

  • Learn More

Make Your Own Gemstone Engagement Ring

Find a gemstone as unique as your partner. Shop from our huge inventory of certified natural colored gems and pair it with a ring setting of your preferred metal. Our designs vary from minimalist chic to timeless classics. Pick your favorite gemstone to create a piece that really defines your style.

Start With Gemstone

Select a gem of your desired color and size from our unmatched treasure of gemstones. Then select your preferred metal and style to get your stunning piece.

Start With Setting

Select the style and shape of your ring from a collection of enthralling designs. Then make it yours with your favorite gemstone. Change your settings anytime.

Shop Our Preset Gemstone Rings Collection

Redefining Luxury is our motto. Shop our most popular pieces from our pre-set collection of ruby, emerald and sapphire engagement rings. Our preset collection is a manifestation of our philosophy. Buy your ring from our preset collection with confidence without worrying about the gem or the setting.

Buy direct. No middleman. Mines to your doorstep.

Our mission is to educate customers with full transparency. All jewelry handcrafted in NYC. Luxury and Quality don't have to come at a cost - they are standard at GemsNY!

  • View Gems in 360

    View Gems in 360

  • All Gems Certified

    All Gems Certified

  • 100% Conflict Free

    100% Conflict Free

  • Best Price Guarantee

    Best Price Guarantee

  • Lifetime Warranty

    Lifetime Warranty

Shop Popular Gemstone Rings

See our favorites to get inspired

Traditional Solitaire


Traditional Solitaire

Princess Diana Replica


Princess Diana Replica

Classic Three Stone


Classic Three Stone




Classic Pave


Classic Pave




Split Shank


Split Shank







Flexible Payment Options

We make it easy to buy now and pay later so you don't need to wait to get your dream gemstones and jewelry

Up to 36 months financing available.

Learn More

Choose from 3, 6, 9 or 12 months interest free payments at checkout.

Learn More

Layaway options are available. Contact us at

Learn More
Learn More

Note: All financing options will be available at checkout

Shop by Metal

Our fine jewelry collection of diamond and gemstone offers hand-crafted pieces of unforgettable luxury, perfect for any occasion. Shop your gemstone ring with your desired metal.

FAQs About Gemstone Engagement Rings

We have answered here the most common questions related to gemstones engagement rings

  • What types of gemstones are available for engagement rings at GemsNY?

    At GemsNY, we use only natural colored gemstones in our engagement rings. The most sought after color gemstones are sapphire, ruby, emerald, alexandrite, tsavorite, tanzanite, tourmaline etc.

  • How do I choose the right size and shape of gemstone for my engagement ring?

    You need to know the size of your finger and based on that you can use our virtual ring sizer tool to see how a stone-size will appear on your finger. You can tweak the gemstone shape to see various options.

  • What types of gemstones are typically used in engagement rings?

    Color gemstones have become the new choice for engagement rings eliminating the dominance of diamonds to a certain degree. Almost all naturally occurring gemstones are used nowadays in gemstone engagement rings.

  • Can I find a unique or custom gemstone engagement ring at GemsNY?

    Yes we have some custom gemstone engagement rings in our inventory in our ready to ship section though we mostly make custom rings on demand. Visit here to learn more.

  • Can I customize my gemstone engagement ring?

    Yes of course you can customize your gemstone engagement ring. Each component of the ring is customizable whether it is the center stone, accent stones, metal or setting.

  • Are gemstone engagement rings less expensive than diamond engagement rings?

    It depends on the size and quality of the gemstone. Many color gemstones command a higher price per carat than diamond. But generally speaking, gemstone engagement rings are a more affordable and colorful option as opposed to a diamond engagement ring.

  • How do I choose the right gemstone for my engagement ring?

    There are many ways to choose the right gemstone for your engagement ring. You can consider your birthstone or your zodiac sign or simply your preference toward a specific color. Or maybe you pick a gemstone that is dear to your significant other.

  • What factors should I consider when selecting a gemstone for my engagement ring?

    Besides budget, you should consider the color, clarity and size of your gemstone. Also factor in the setting required for any specific shape of a gemstone and how it looks on you. Don’t forget to match it with the color of metal you want for your engagement ring.

Consult Our Jewelry Specialists

A more thoughtful way to experience fine jewelry, built around you.

Visit Showroom
GemsNY Showroom