Gemstone Engagement Rings

Gemstones made by nature, settings carefully handcrafted in NYC for you.

  • Split your payment Flexible Financing

  • customer can pay in up to 2 years * Up to 24 month term

  • Credit history icon* No Credit Check Available

  • Interest Free Icon * 0% APR Available

  • Learn More
Shop by Gemstone

By Direct - We own our entire inventory - offering you unmatched selection, pricing and details about each item. Contact our gemologists on staff to discuss specific gemstones in real time

Buy direct. No middleman. Mines to your doorstep.

Our mission is to educate customers with full transparency. All jewelry handcrafted in NYC. Luxury and Quality doesn’t have to come at a cost – its standard at GemsNY!

  • Real look of Gems

    View Gems in 360

  • Certified Gemstones

    All Gems Certified

  • Absolutely genuine

    100% Conflict Free

  • Best Valued Products

    Best Price Guarantee

  • lifetime icon

    Lifetime Warranty

Shop Popular Gemstone Engagement Rings

See our favorites to get inspired

Popular Traditional Solitaire Ring - R10211BS

R10211BS

Traditional Solitaire

Popular Princess Diana Replica Ring - R11835BS

R11835BS

Princess Diana Replica

Popular Classic Three Stone Ring - R10694BS

R10694BS

Classic Three Stone

Popular Halo Ring - R10211BS

R11779BS

Halo

Popular Classic Pave Ring - R10264BS

R10264BS

Classic Pave

Popular Celtic Ring - R11659BS

R11659BS

Celtic

Popular Split Shank Ring - R11357BS

R11357BS

Split Shank

Popular Bypass Ring - R11329BS

R11329BS

Bypass

Popular Wedding Set Ring - RB11356BS

RB11356BS

Wedding Set

Popular Antique Ring - R10211BS

R11744BS

Antique

Easy Financing

We make it easy to buy now and pay later so you don't need to wait to get your dream gemstones and jewelry

  • financing card icon

    Up to 24 months financing available. Prequalify now

  • Easy EMI icon

    Choose from 3, 6, 9 or 12 months interest free payments with no credit check. Learn More

  • Credit check icon

    With Paypal Credit, no interest if paid in full in 6 months or pay in 4 payments. Learn more

  • Layaway options icon

    Layaway options are available. Contact us at info@gemsny.com

Shop by Metal

Our diamond and gemstone fine jewelry collection
offers hand-crafted pieces of unforgettable luxury that are perfect for any occasion.

Shop All Right Arrow

Consult with a Jewelry Specialist

A more thoughtful way to experience fine jewelry, built around you.

Visit Showroom
GemsNY Showroom
Shopping Cart (ID# )
Login to save your shopping cart
Close