Gemstone Engagement Ring Gemstone Engagement Ring

Gemstone Rings

Gemstones made by nature, settings carefully handcrafted in NYC for you. Find the perfect ring from our precious and semiprecious gemstone rings collection.

  • Split your payment Flexible Financing

  • customer can pay in up to 2 years * Up to 36 months term

  • Credit history icon* No Credit Check Available

  • Interest Free Icon * 0% APR Available

  • Learn More

Make Your Own Gemstone Ring

Life is always better in color. Shop our wide array of certified natural colored gems and pair it with a ring setting of your preferred metal. Our designs vary from minimalist chic to timeless antiques. Pick your favorite gemstone to create a piece that really defines your style.

Start With Gemstone

Our gemstone rings settings are carefully crafted in the heart of NYC! Choose a setting that's uniquely yours, then select your desired metal finish and pair it with one of our natural gemstones for a stunning piece!

Start With Setting

Our settings are carefully crafted in the heart of NYC! Choose a setting that's uniquely you, then select your desired metal finish and pair it with one of our natural gemstones for a stunning piece!

Shop Our Preset Gemstone Rings Collection

Shop our most popular pieces from our pre-set collection of ruby, emerald and sapphire rings. Once you've settled on a design, personalize your selection by choosing the size and quality of your desired gem, your desired ring metal, and you're all set! Our GIA-certified gemologists on staff will then handpick the best selection, based on the requested attributes and our design team will make the perfect setting to bring your creation to life. The preset gemstone rings collection allows for perfected pieces in only a few clicks.

Buy direct. No middleman. Mines to your doorstep.

Our mission is to educate customers with full transparency. All jewelry handcrafted in NYC. Luxury and Quality doesn’t have to come at a cost – its standard at GemsNY!

  • View Gems in 360

    View Gems in 360

  • All Gems Certified

    All Gems Certified

  • 100% Conflict Free

    100% Conflict Free

  • Best Price Guarantee

    Best Price Guarantee

  • Lifetime Warranty

    Lifetime Warranty

Shop Popular Gemstone Rings

See our favorites to get inspired

Traditional Solitaire


Traditional Solitaire

Princess Diana Replica


Princess Diana Replica

Classic Three Stone


Classic Three Stone




Classic Pave


Classic Pave




Split Shank


Split Shank







Flexible Payment Options

We make it easy to buy now and pay later so you don't need to wait to get your dream gemstones and jewelry

Up to 36 months financing available.

Learn More

Choose from 3, 6, 9 or 12 months interest free payments at checkout.

Learn More

With Paypal Pay Later, no interest if paid in full in 4 months. Select Paypal Pay Later at Paypal checkout.

Learn More

Layaway options are available. Contact us at

Learn More
Learn More

Note: All financing options will be available at checkout

Shop by Metal

Our fine jewelry collection of diamond and gemstone offers hand-crafted pieces of unforgettable luxury, perfect for any occasion. Shop your gemstone ring with your desired metal.

FAQs About Gemstone Rings

We have answered here the most common questions related to gemstone rings

  • What to look for when buying a gemstone ring?

    Check for the size of the ring. We offer one time free resizing. Then check the color, clarity and size of the gemstone as well as the metal suitable for your skin tone.

  • What types of gemstones are commonly used in gemstone rings?

    Gemstone rings come with many options. The most commonly used gemstones are sapphires, rubies, emeralds, alexandrites, tanzanites and many more. Diamonds are also used as accent stones.

  • How do I choose the right size for my gemstone ring?

    Measure the circumference of the finger you want to wear your ring on and then refer to our size chart. A colored gemstone ring of the right size will save you a lot of trouble later on.

  • Can I customize the design of my gemstone ring?

    Yes of course you can customize your gemstone ring in the metal you want, in the style you prefer and with the gemstone of your preference.

  • Which finger do you wear a gemstone ring?

    Gemstone rings can be worn on any finger unless it is an engagement ring or a wedding ring which are worn on specific fingers. If it’s your birthstone ring, it should be worn on the correct finger astrologically.

  • What are the benefits of wearing gemstone rings?

    Each gemstone is associated with certain lore and symbolism but all gemstone rings bring positivity & prosperity to your life if the gemstone it features suits you astrologically.

  • How do I care for my gemstone ring to ensure its longevity and beauty?

    Store your gemstone ring separate from other jewelry pieces specially diamonds to avoid scratching. Occasionally clean your ring with a mild solution of soap and water. Also get it checked from a professional jeweler every couple of years.

  • How can I tell whether the stone in a gemstone ring is natural or synthetic?

    There is no way an untrained person can differentiate between a synthetic and natural gemstone.The best solution is to purchase it from a reputed seller and get a certificate of authenticity from labs such as GIA, AGL etc.

  • What types of natural gemstones are used in GemsNY's rings?

    GemsNY uses only natural gemstones in its colored gemstone ring and all of your colored gemstones are certified. All of our jewelry is backed by our lifetime warranty against any manufacturing flaws.

Consult Our Jewelry Specialists

A more thoughtful way to experience fine jewelry, built around you.

Visit Showroom
GemsNY Showroom